European Legal System Single channel

Chair (Coordinator) and Rapporteur: GIANLUCA SCARCHILLO

Objectives

GENERAL OBJECTIVES

The aims of the course are:

a) to introduce the study of comparative law;

b) to identify the aspects that characterize the main Western legal

systems of civil and common law;

c) to investigate the evolution of the model of joint-stock

company in European company law.

SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES

Knowledge and understanding (knowledge and understanding)

The student must demonstrate complete knowledge and

understanding of civil law and common law systems.Applied knowledge and understanding (applying knowledge and

understanding):

The student will have to demonstrate an in-depth knowledge of

the methods of legal comparison, of the main codifications of

western legal tradition, of the other systems of law and of the

evolution of European company law

Making judgments:

The student must demonstrate the ability to integrate knowledge

and manage complexity, as well as to formulate judgments based

on limited or incomplete information, including reflection on

social and ethical responsibilities related to the application of his

knowledge and judgments with particular reference to systems

comparative private law firms.

Communication skills (communication skills):

Ability to communicate goals, contexts and consequences of law

policies, also company law, with particular reference to

comparative legal systems

Learning skills (learning skills):

Ability to develop legal documents and the ability to interpret

and apply the rules of the national and foreign legal system,

measuring convergences and divergences. The ability to find,

even through databases, understand and use national and foreign

legislation, jurisprudence and doctrine.


Learning outcomes

Knowledge and understanding: solid basic training.
Applied knowledge and understanding: problem solving skills.
Autonomy of judgment: ability to analyze and evaluate.
Communication: ability to interact.
Ability to learn: good study methodology.

Prerequisites

Prerequisites for private law institutions and public law institutions are required.
For a better learning and a better understanding of the subject it is necessary, both for the first part and for the second part, that the student has a knowledge of private and public law institutions at the beginning of the teaching activities in order to have the introductory and basic notions for the analysis of the various legal systems and institutions treated during the course.
For the special part, in addition to the knowledge of private law institutions, the basic knowledge of the joint-stock company is useful, a typical instrument of commercial and corporate law.

Programme

THE EUROPEAN LEGAL SYSTEMS COURSE IS DIVIDED INTO THREE MODULES:

I module (2CFU):
Comparative Law: development, object, purpose, classification of legal systems
II module (5 CFU):
The Western legal tradition and the principal legal systems of civil and common law: the historical evolution, the sources of law, the formation of a lawyer, the legal profession, and notes on some characteristic institutes. Brief presentation of legal tradition of countries in which the Western legal tradition has, at different levels, "circulated": Nordic countries, Latin America countries, China, Japan, India and Islamic countries.
III module (2 CFU):
The module will be focus on the study of the EC Regulation on the Statute for a European Company (SE - Societas Europea) in the context of the evolution of the model of joint stock companies in the contemporaries European systems.

Books

MODULE I E II:

K. Zweigert - H. Kotz - Introduction to comparative law - vol. I - Clarendon Press - Oxford - 1987

MODULE III:

- AA.VV., THE EUROPEAN COMPANY, COMMUNITY SOURCES AND NATIONAL MODELS, BY D. CORAPI AND F. PERNAZZA, GIAPPICHELLI, TORINO, EXTRACT 2017MODULI I E II:

Bibliography

MODULO I E II:

GORLA, voce Diritto Comparato e straniero, in Enc. Dir., 1964.
GORLA, voce Diritto Comparato e straniero, in Enc. Giur., 1989.
GORLA, Diritto Comparato e Diritto Comune Europeo, Milano, 1981.
GORLA, Prolegomeni ad una storia del diritto comparato europeo, in Foro it., 1980, V.
GORLA-MOCCIA, Profili di una storia del "diritto comparato" in Italia e nel mondo comunicante, in Riv. dir. civ., 1987, 242.
GORLA-MOCCIA, A "Revisiting" of the comparison between "Continental Law" and "English Law", in The Journal of Legal History, 1981, 43.
MOCCIA, Prospetto storico delle origini e degli atteggiamenti del moderno diritto comparato, in Riv. trim. dir. proc. civ., 1996, 181.
MOCCIA, Glossario per uno studio della common law, Milano, 1981.
ZWEIGERT-KÖTZ, Introduzione al diritto comparato, vol. I + vol. II.
DAVID, I grandi sistemi giuridici contemporanei, 1984.
GALGANO, Atlante di diritto privato comparato, 1993.
SACCO, Introduzione al diritto comparato.
SACCO, voce Diritti stranieri e sistemi di diritto contemporaneo, in Enc. Giur., 1989.
AA.VV., Diritto privato comparato. Istituti e problemi, Bari, 1999.
STEIN, Diritto privato europeo.
MERRYMAN-STEIN, voce Common law, in Enc. Giur.
ALPA, Corso di sistemi giuridici comparati, 1996.
COSTANTINESCO, Introduzione al diritto comparato.
MATTEI, Il modello di common law.
MONATERI, Il modello di civil law.
ALPA, Il contratto nei sistemi di common law, in Nov. Dig. It.
MOCCIA, Premessa e contratto, in Riv. dir. civ., 1994, 819.
MOCCIA, voce Contract, in Enc. Giur.
CRISCUOLI, Contract.
GILMORE, La morte del contratto.
ZENO ZENCOVICH, Il diritto europeo dei contratti, in Giur. it., 1993, 57.
DAVID, Unificazione internazionale del diritto, in Enc. Giur., 1994.
BONELL, Unificazione internazionale del diritto, in Enc. Dir., 1992.
BONELL, Un codice europeo dei contratti del commercio internazionale.
HARTKAMP, HESSELINK et al., Towards a European Civil Code, II ed., L’Aja, 1998.
WITZ, Plaidoyer pour un code éuropéen des obligations, Dalloz 2000, chr. 79.
LEGRAND, Against a European Civil Code, 60 Modern Law Review 44 (1997).
BONELL, The Need and Possibilities of a Codified European Contract Law, 5 Eur. Rev. Private Law 505, (1997).
MARKESINIS, Why a Code Is not the Best Way to Advance the Cause of European Legal Unity, 5 Eur. Rev. Private Law 519, (1997).
BASEDOW, Un droit commun des contrcts pour le marché commun, Rev. int. dr. comparé, 1998,7.
ZENO ZENCOVICH, Il codice civile europeo, le tradizioni giuridiche nazionali e il neopositivismo, Foro it. 1998, V.

Lessons mode

The course is divided into lectures, with slides and video projections, with the formulation of questions and the dialogical use of the arguments, according to didactic methods that foresee the continuous participation of the students, by stimulating analysis and debate on topics covered. Foreign materials will be provided in the original language (such as judgments, legislative texts, etc.), on which written exercises will take place at the end of each module and oral exercises will be presented as a case of the most recent jurisprudence and foreign doctrine. In-depth seminars are also planned with foreign professors on current topics of particular interest in order to better understand the most important foreign legal experiences.



Frequency

Attendance at lectures, although optional, is strongly recommended. Attendance at lectures will be collected through the collection of student signatures present in the classroom and through participation in aptitude tests carried out during the course for the evaluation of the comprehension of the various topics addressed.
The student who will be attending for having attended at least 60 hours of lessons may choose to prepare the final exam on alternative materials, agreed with the teacher during the course, and may present a written essay on a monographic topic, analyzed with the tools of comparison, preparatory to a possible comparative degree thesis. The written essay will be the object of the oral examination

Exam mode

During the course three multiple-choice aptitude tests will be carried out at the end of each module to assess students' ongoing understanding. Attending students who have taken all three aptitude tests without any errors will receive a bonus of three points in the final evaluation.
Oral exam. This assessment method allows the assessment of the analytical and critical skills required of the student to be assessed in the most complete manner, in addition to the student's communication skills, in consideration of the complexity of the topics and the arguments object of the course which he must demonstrate knowledge of. the comprehension.
Expected learning outcomes will be evaluated by formulating three or more questions. The evaluation criteria and scores are determined according to the following scale:
• less than 18/30 - insufficient level: the candidate does not reach any of the learning outcomes foreseen in the point "knowledge and understanding";
• 18-20 / 30 - sufficient level: the candidate achieves, in particular, the learning outcomes foreseen in the point "knowledge and understanding";
• 21-23 / 30 - fully sufficient level: the candidate achieves, in particular, the learning outcomes envisaged under the points "knowledge and understanding" and "applied understanding and understanding";
• 24-26 / 30 - good level: the candidate achieves, in particular, the learning outcomes foreseen in the points "knowledge and understanding"; "Applied understanding and understanding" and "independent judgment";
• 27-29 / 30 - very good level: the candidate achieves, in particular, the learning outcomes foreseen in the points "knowledge and understanding"; "Applied understanding and understanding"; "Autonomy of judgment" and "communication skills";
• 30-30 cum laude - excellent level: the candidate fully achieves the learning outcomes foreseen in the points "knowledge and understanding"; "Applied understanding and understanding"; "Autonomy of judgment"; "Communication skills" and "ability to learn".

Example exam questions

INTRODUCTION TO COMPARATIVE LAW

1. Comparative law and legal "transplants": precautions and examples.
2. Classification of legal systems: indicate the distinctive criteria proposed (by David, Zweigert and Kötz, Mattei) and illustrate the limits and relativity of the classifications.

COMMON LAW UK
1. Illustrate the evolution of the writ of trespass (from trespass vi et armis to assumpsit) and indicate the current penalties for breach of contract deriving from common law and equity.
2. Illustrate the role of the writs and royal courts of Westminster in the evolution of English law.

COMMON LAW USA
1. With reference to US law, illustrate the fundamental features of the due process clause (procedural and substantive) and of the "penumbra rights".
2. With reference to US law, illustrate the division of legislative competence between States and the federal State in the light of the provisions of the X Amendment and of art. 1 of the Constitution and the role played by the "necessary and proper clause" and by the "interstate commerce clause".

CIVIL LAW
1. French Civil Code and BGB: roots, style and structure compared.
2. Illustrate the process of adaptation of the civil code by the legislator, jurisprudence and doctrine.

TRUSTS
1. After a brief description of the trust structure, indicate who is the prominent figure and why.

CONTRACT IN COMPARATIVE LAW
1. The legal transaction in German and Italian law
2. Causal and abstract contract in comparative law
3. Contract and consideration in English law

Arguments

  • Programming follows that of the Faculty and is posted on Infostud

Sustainability goals

  • Goal10
  • Goal16
  • Goal17
  • Academic year2026/2027
  • Degree program to which the course belongsEuropean studies
  • Lesson code10625783
  • Year and semester1st year - 2nd semester
  • Activity typeAttività formative affini ed integrative
  • Academic areaAttività formative affini o integrative
  • SSDGIUR-11/A
  • Mandatory presenceNo
  • LanguageENG
  • CFU6 CFU
  • Total duration48 hours
  • Hours distribution48 classroom hours